It is one of the oldest pieces of winter driving advice in Canada, and it is wrong for the roads you actually drive. The claim goes like this: let some air out of your tires and the bigger, softer footprint will grip snow and ice better. It sounds like physics. On a plowed GTA street, on the 401, on an icy side road in Durham, it does the opposite of what you want — and this week is exactly when the mistake gets made, because the weather is about to play a trick on your tire pressures whether you touch a valve stem or not.

Start with that weather, because it sets the trap. Toronto is in the middle of an unusually mild November run: mostly sunny, with highs around 13 to 15 degrees through Thursday and the weekend. Then the turn arrives. By Monday, November 23, the high falls to about 6 degrees with an overnight low near minus 2, and Tuesday sits near 3 degrees. That is a swing of roughly ten degrees in a few days. Transport Canada puts a number on what that does inside a tire: pressure falls by about 7 kilopascals — roughly 1 psi — for every 5 degrees Celsius the air cools. A set of tires filled correctly during this mild week will read about 2 psi lower after the cold lands, without leaking a thing. Drivers who do not know that rule reach for folk remedies. Drivers who do know it just top up to the placard and drive. This article is about why the folk remedy — deliberately running soft — is the one move you should never make.

Where the myth comes from: a real technique, in the wrong place

The idea did not appear from nowhere. Off-road drivers genuinely do air down. On deep, loose surfaces — sand, mud, unplowed trails — at low speeds, a softer tire spreads its footprint and can help a vehicle float and crawl instead of digging in. That world has almost nothing in common with winter commuting in the GTA. Off-road airing down happens at walking-to-moderate speeds, on surfaces with no pavement underneath, usually with tires and wheels chosen for it, and the pressure goes back up before the vehicle returns to the road.

Your winter drive is the reverse of every one of those conditions. The surface is pavement with a thin, hard, slippery layer on top of it — packed snow, slush, or ice. The speeds are city and highway speeds. The job of the tire is not to float over the surface; it is to press its tread edges and sipes into that thin layer, clear the slush out of its channels, and hold a stable shape while you steer and brake. A winter tire is engineered to do that job at one specific thing: its correct inflation pressure.

What underinflation actually does to a winter tire

Let air out and the tire does not simply get a bigger footprint. It changes shape in the wrong places. The sidewalls flex more, the tread rolls onto its shoulders, and the centre of the tread — where many of the biting edges and drainage channels live — carries less of the load. The contact patch gets longer but less evenly pressed, steering response goes vague, and the tire runs hotter from all that extra flexing, even in winter.

Transport Canada is blunt about the costs of running underinflated: it increases rolling resistance, which reduces tread life and increases fuel consumption, and it can lead to sudden tire failure. Add the winter-specific problems. A soft tire clears slush less effectively because its channels are distorted. It is more likely to suffer rim damage when it meets a frost-heaved pothole, because there is less air cushion between the road and the wheel. And on ice — the surface where drivers most hope the trick will help — a deformed tread with uneven pressure is the last thing you want between you and the road. The grip was never in the extra air you removed. It is in the compound, the tread design, and the shape the tire holds at proper pressure.

The pressure drop you did not cause — and the right response to it

Here is the part of the story that matters this week. Most underinflated winter tires in the GTA were never deflated by anyone. They went low on their own, for two ordinary reasons Transport Canada quantifies. First, cold: about 1 psi lost for every 5-degree drop in temperature, which is why a mild mid-November week followed by a hard turn — exactly the forecast in front of us — quietly takes a couple of psi out of every tire in the region. Second, permeability: tires also lose roughly 14 kilopascals, about 2 psi, per month through the tire itself, leak or no leak.

Stack those two together and a tire that was perfect in October can be meaningfully low by late November. The correct response is boring, cheap, and complete: check the pressure and restore it to the vehicle manufacturer's number. Not the maximum pressure moulded into the tire's sidewall — that is a limit, not a target. The target is on the tire information label, usually on the driver's door edge or door post, and it is the pressure your vehicle's handling, braking, and load capacity were designed around.

The opposite mistake: overinflating "for the cold coming"

Once drivers learn that cold steals pressure, some try to outsmart it by adding extra air in advance. Do not. An overinflated tire has its own problems: the contact patch shrinks and crowns toward the centre of the tread, the centre wears faster, and the tire rides harsher over broken winter pavement. You cannot pre-pay a pressure debt, because you do not know exactly how cold it will get or for how long — and on the mild days in between, you are driving on too much air. Set the placard pressure, checked cold, and recheck it after the weather swings. That is the whole system, and it works.

How to check pressure properly, in five minutes

Transport Canada's routine is simple. Measure every tire — the spare included — at least once a month through the winter, and after any sharp temperature swing like the one arriving November 23. Measure cold: a tire counts as cold when the vehicle has sat for at least three hours, or has been driven no more than about 2 kilometres. A reading taken after a highway run reads high, because driving warms the air inside the tire, and a set filled to the number while warm will be low the next cold morning.

Use a proper gauge. Transport Canada notes that pocket gauges from an auto supply store are generally more accurate than the gauges built into gas station air pumps. Check all four corners, not just the one that looks low — a tire can be several psi down and still look fine, because modern sidewalls are stiff enough to hide it. And treat your tire pressure monitoring system as a backstop, not a gauge: Transport Canada cautions that some systems warn only when a tire is significantly underinflated, by which point it may already be close to failure. If the light comes on during next week's cold snap, that is the temperature rule introducing itself — check all four tires that day rather than waiting for the light to change its mind. We covered the light itself in our guide to the TPMS light in cold weather.

Pressure is one leg of the stool — the tire itself is the other

None of this rescues the wrong tire. Correct pressure on a worn-out winter tire, or on an all-season that has gone hard in the cold, still leaves you short of grip. Pressure works together with the things we keep coming back to in Tire Intel: a full set of four matching winter tires, because two winter tires are not enough; tread depth that can still clear slush; and the three-peak mountain snowflake designation on the sidewall. If you are shopping for the set itself, start with verified sizes and fitment in the tire and wheel shop, compare complete setups on the tire and wheel packages page, and check the current offers on the tire rebates page before you buy.

What Sparky X checks at every winter install

Every seasonal changeover and package install we do finishes the same way: precision computer balancing, lug nuts torqued to the manufacturer's specification, and pressures set cold to the door placard for that specific vehicle — not a one-number-fits-all figure. Winter tire and wheel packages include free mobile installation, and Tesla packages include pre-programmed Bluetooth TPMS sensors. If your pressures were set during a mild spell and the cold has now landed, a five-minute gauge check at home covers you; if the tires themselves are the problem, that is a conversation we are happy to have in your driveway.

Sparky X is fully mobile across Toronto, the GTA, Durham and York — the work happens at your home or workplace. Our office is at 60 Hoile Drive in Ajax; it is office only, and no vehicle service happens there. Sparky X does not offer tire storage, so your off-season set stays with you. Read how the services work on the services page or check the FAQs before you book.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does letting air out of my tires help in snow?
No — not on paved winter roads. Airing down is a low-speed off-road technique for deep, loose surfaces. On plowed streets and highways, an underinflated winter tire distorts its tread, loads its shoulders, clears slush poorly, and steers vaguely. Winter tires are designed to grip at the manufacturer's recommended pressure, which is printed on the driver's door label.

Why did my tire pressure drop when it got cold?
Because air contracts as it cools. Transport Canada puts the loss at about 7 kilopascals, roughly 1 psi, for every 5 degrees Celsius the temperature falls. Tires also lose about 2 psi a month through the tire itself. A sharp cold swing like the one forecast for November 23 can take a couple of psi out of a correctly filled tire with nothing wrong with it.

What pressure should my winter tires be at?
The pressure on your vehicle's tire information label — usually on the driver's door edge or door post — measured when the tires are cold. Do not use the maximum pressure shown on the tire sidewall; that is a limit, not the target. Do not add extra air to compensate for cold that has not arrived yet, and do not run below the placard figure for grip.

How often should I check tire pressure in winter?
At least once a month, and after any sharp temperature swing. Check when the tires are cold — the vehicle has sat for at least three hours or been driven no more than about 2 kilometres — and check all four tires plus the spare. A dashboard TPMS warning is a backstop, not a substitute: some systems only warn when a tire is already significantly underinflated.

The bottom line

The air-down trick belongs on a trail, at low speed, in deep loose terrain. On GTA winter roads it takes a properly designed winter tire and bends it out of the shape that gives it grip — while raising fuel use, shortening tread life, and adding a failure risk Transport Canada warns about directly. This week's mild weather followed by next week's cold turn will lower pressures across the region all by itself. Your job is the simple one: a gauge, the door placard number, checked cold, once a month and after every big swing. Keep the air. It is doing more for your grip than letting it out ever will.

Need winter tires fitted, balanced, and set to the correct pressure at your home or workplace? Book the visit online and we will come to you.

Book online: sparkyx.ca/book
Call or text: (647) 819-0490

Sparky X Mobile Tire Shop — fully mobile across Toronto, the GTA, Durham and York. Our office is at 60 Hoile Drive in Ajax; all service happens at your home or workplace. We come to you.